Press "Enter" to skip to content

DePaul Men Share Thoughts on “Cornell Seven” & Rape Culture

Where are the men in this conversation? Right here.

Recently, online platforms have been buzzing with posts about the legal case coined “Cornell 7.” On Oct. 19, 2024, the plaintiff Jane Doe alleged an incident of being drugged and gang-raped by members of Cornell University’s Fraternity Chi Phi. Two years later, Doe is pursuing legal action against these men.

Across Instagram, images of alleged perpetrators Matthew Ingalls, Jonathan Newell, Winston Lee, Gillio Lopes, Diego Sarabia, Scott Norris and Scott Kretzschmar are circling everywhere. Included in these posts are messages from mainly women expressing their solidarity with Doe and frustrations with rape culture.

Celebrities are also chiming in with Hollywood actress Florence Pugh sharing her thoughts on Instagram, noting the underwhelming amount of men contributing to the conversation.

“This is really the moment where we need our men to be as horrified and as sickened as us,” Pugh wrote, “How can you expect us to trust that it’s ‘not all men’ when in moments like this, many of you stay quiet?”

To Pugh’s point, where are the men — not only in the conversation surrounding Cornell University — but in overall discussions of rape culture? At DePaul University, some men decided to share their opinion.

Overall, they knew basic facts about the case: it occurred at a frat party, ketamine was involved, “free p*ssy” was sent in a Snapchat group chat and that the men had the option to submit an essay to mitigate punishment.

When DePaul biology major Trip Dolan heard about the case, it hit close to home.

“I think they need to be jailed for the rest of their lives,” Dolan said, “As someone who is a victim of sexual assault, I cannot express the amount of grief I know she must be feeling. Any form of justice would be better than them being out and free.”

Dolan had various conversations with his friends on the case, but saw a difference in engagement and depth between women and straight men.

With women, conversations led to vulnerable disclosures of their own related-struggles.

“One of my friends had a rape kit submitted ten years ago and it still hasn’t been tested. She had to pay for all her other things out of pocket too,” Dolan said, “She had to pay for medication after everything happened to prevent HIV and AIDS. She had to pay for her own therapy. She almost dropped out of school.” 

With straight men though, there was a stark difference. By the end, Dolan was able to see where “people’s priorities lie.”

“All of my friends who were heterosexual men just glossed over it, or didn’t speak about it, or if the topic was brought up in conversation, it got dropped immediately,” Dolan said.

A photograph of Trip Dolan.

But why? Communications major Nickolas Gelashvili, said that he is aware of what’s being said, and agrees that the “Cornell Seven” didn’t receive proper punishment, but can be shy to share his opinion. Still, if asked directly, he will give his thoughts.

“I’m not blinded by the conversations that are happening. I’m still seeing them and listening to them, but not every conversation is one that I have to be in on,” Gelashvili said.

Gelashvili is worried about the social consequences: being ostracized by friends, thought of differently or even facing death.

“Worst case scenario, look at Charlie Kirk. Granted, not all of his thoughts were the best, however they were his opinions,” Gelashvili said, “It’s sad that a man who was sharing his opinions died, and was killed.”

A photograph of Nickolas Gelashvili.

Others are not uncomfortable with the consequence of speaking up, but have their limits due to the nature of the topic.

Both accounting majors, Demoyne Thomas and Hasan Siddiqui believe big events like “Cornell Seven” is the time to discuss rape.

“I feel like that’s our job as men, we have to defend women in some cases. So, when it’s something as big as this, I feel like it has to be talked about,” Thomas said, “You’re gonna want to help the person get justice if it keeps coming up.”

“I think the severity of it needs to be discussed more,” Siddiqui said, “It’s better to be educated about an unsettling topic than be uneducated.”

Beyond basic facts about major incidents, it’s too uncomfortable for them to discuss or learn more about it.

“I think it’s good to talk about this stuff and be aware, but at some point, like looking into it, it does feel very unsettling to hear something this crazy is happening,” Siddiqui said.

While they agree people should understand foundationally what rape is, it shouldn’t be a consistent conversation.

“I don’t think I’ll ever be compelled to just talk about that topic a lot,” Thomas said, “I don’t think anybody should be overly motivated to just try to talk about things like that all the time. How are you supposed to think about good things if you just always think about the negative?”

A photograph of Deymoyne Thomas (left) and Hasan Siddiqui (right).

Economics and finance major Marco Montoya somewhat aligns on that there’s other things to think about. When he learned about the case, did he feel inclined to learn more? Yes. But did he actually?

“I don’t really keep up with a lot of news other than financial news, which is really bad, but that’s all that employers care about,” Montoya said, “It’s [Cornell Seven] not very important to me right now, at this moment. What’s important to me right now, at this moment, is finding a job that pays me well.”

Montoya is busy going to coffee chats with professionals, learning Excel spreadsheets and trying to secure an internship. Everything else? On the back-burner— but that’s normal between him and his friends. They sit around and discuss if J.P. Morgan is hiring and who got an interview with Bank of America, not the political state of the world.

In general, his attitude is that survival comes first. Using the example of the War in Iran, he says people don’t care if it’s pointless, only that it raises their gas prices and interest rates because this is affecting a larger group of people and their ability to survive, it takes precedence over other issues like “Cornell Seven.”

But, he does understand the significance of action.

“I feel like it’s more important to raise awareness on what we, as students, as the people, can really do to prevent or demand some sort of action from administrations or institutions,” Montoya said.

A photograph of Marco Montoya.

Education major Carter Baughman disagrees — conversations need to happen within communities early on and more often to create better institutional responses to rape.

“From my own personal circle, we were talking about that, but that’s a small bubble,” Baughman said, “If it was being talked about enough, then we would have a better solution to their punishment than write a couple of papers. And, I think that a lot of the problem is we refuse to talk about the harder stuff.”

Baughman discusses the importance of existing in diverse spaces. As a student employee for the DePaul Career Center, he gets to learn from the perspectives of his female co-workers. But in fraternities, he says, they exist in an echo chamber.

A photograph of Carter Baughman.

Along those lines, Dolan points out the need for early-on development of consent, even outside of a sexual context.

“There’s such a lack of teaching about respect,” Dolan says, “It’s boys will be boys. If you hit a girl, you like her. If you tease someone, you like them. These forms of harm are seen as affection and desire, and a lack of consent comes from that.”

In a study done by Jezebel, of the forty-eight adult men asked when they formally learned about consent, more than three quarters didn’t even know about the word until college. An average of 107,418 men are perpetrators of rape each year, and 89% of reported victims are women.

When these conversations between and with men that foster respect and consent don’t happen, they continue to feel comfortable in silence, uncomfortable in discussion and impartial to action. And unfortunately, encouraged to commit violence.

As a result, cases like “Cornell Seven” and the ideology surrounding it persists.

“The excusing of thousands of rapists every year manifests in this way that even the most heinous actions are overlooked. The enabling of rape culture in politics, media and social interactions daily, unfortunately, reflect what kind of society America has come to,” Dolan said.  

Header Image by Cora Bowen

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply